Schrade “Extreme Survival” OTF
Review by Phil Elmore
Those of you who remember the Bokermatic know that Schrade’s
new “assisted opening OTF” (“Out the Front”) knife, produced under the “Schrade
Extreme Survival” label, is not really that new a concept — though of course there
is no Schrade Cutlery anymore, so Schrade itself is a sub-brand of its new
owner. Taylor Brands, LLC, best known for producing the licensed Smith and
Wesson knives, bought the rights to the Schrade name when that venerable
American knife company went under. It has been my experience that the quality
exhibited by Taylor-made knives is middle-of-the-road to mediocre at best. The
Schrade OTF is no exception.
The knife is a
Zytel frame with a metal channel sandwiched inside, bearing a three-inch
titanium-nitride coated blade that is something between a clip point and a spear
point. Overall length is seven inches. The Zytel handle is about three quarters
of an inch thick — which is fairly chunky. The metal pocket clip, affixed to
the butt of the handle by a pointed striking cap, appears to be removable, but I did not try to remove it. The
knife can be oriented in the pocket with the front down only, which is the only
logical means of carrying an OTF knife if the pocket clip is used.
There
are three controls. The first is a notched, plastic “safety” switch on one side
of the handle. The second is the lever used to push the blade into opening
position, while the third is the lock release attached to the opening lever. The
theory of operation is simple enough: One draws the knife (presumably clipped to
a pocket), releases the safety (used to prevent the knife from shooting open in
the pocket), repositions the hand in order to slide the lever in the open
channel in the handle (you have to hook a finger on the pocket clip on the
obverse to get the leverage for this), and pushes that lever forward. When the
handle has moved roughly an inch, the internal spring takes over and shoots the
blade out the rest of the way under “assisted opening”. The blade locks into
position when open. Pressing the release on the lever allows the user to retract
the blade into the handle until it again locks into position, after which the
user presumably reactivates the safety switch.
In practice, this
was a little more difficult to do than it sounds. The safety switch on my knife
was completely frozen. I could not move it with my thumb no matter how hard I
tried. Finally, I used a pen to shove it open. I then worked it back and forth
several times, using the pen to dislodge it from the locked position for each
transition. Eventually, the safety loosened enough that I was able to move it
into the unlocked position by hooking it with my thumbnail and pushing
hard.
The knife opens
as it is supposed to, but it does not always lock into place. A few times, right
out of the box, it does not open with enough force to engage the lock. The lock
also disengages far too easily. Only the
barest push on the lock release will unlock it. The sound of the spring
compressing when the blade is retracted does not sound all that healthy, if you
ask me. It sounds strained.
The pocket clip
exhibits extreme lateral play, owing to its single point of connection to the
handle. It had decent tension in the pocket apart from this, but the
side-to-side play is so great as to be annoying. The blade on my sample,
however, locks open securely when it is locked, exhibiting only the faintest
lateral play when forcibly pushed against the Zytel frame. It does not move
vertically or on the axis of its spine.
The grooved
handle is comfortable enough, with some grooves for added purchase abnd a
textured surface on the face. I wish there were more grooves, though, as a lot
of the handle is smoother than I’d like. The open channel is a magnet for all
kinds of pocket debris, though.
The blade on my
knife was nicely sharp out of the box and cut very well. It tapers to a
needle-sharp point. That point does not project at all beyond the front opening
(which was a problem on my old Bokermatic).
All in all, the Schrade
“Extreme Survival” OTF is an interesting concept that has been executed by
Taylor in its usual mediocre fashion. Made in Taiwan (as of this writing), the
knife makes a fun toy but would not make a very good daily utility or
self-defense blade. It’s certainly better than nothing, and has a fairly high
“flash factor” thanks to its styling and assisted opening action, but it’s not
what I would consider a serious knife in any category.>>