its paid sponsors, whose products you need!
“Stay ‘unreasonable.’ If you
don’t like the solutions [available to you], come up with your
own.”
Dan Webre
The Martialist does not
constitute legal advice. It is for ENTERTAINMENT
PURPOSES ONLY.
Copyright © 2003-2004 Phil Elmore, all rights
reserved.
ComTech Fighting Bandanna
A Video Review by Phil Elmore
James
A. Keating of Combat Technologies is widely known in martial arts and
combative circles by the title “Master at Arms.” Though he is
probably best known for his reverse grip and bowie knife work, as well as the
FMA influence present in his materials, Mr. Keating often defies
description. He is eclectic, remarkably knowledgeable, extremely
personable, and very good at what he does.
Mr. Keating’s credentials can be both blessing and curse,
however, in that he has a knack for making even the most complex techniques
seem simple and easy to do. This must be kept in mind whenever watching
him move, for what Mr. Keating does with ease might take considerable
practice for the student to achieve. This does not detract from the
value of the huge body of work Keating and ComTech have produced, but it must
be kept in mind when absorbing the material offered.
The
ComTech Combat Bandanna series looks at the kerchief, otherwise known
as the bandanna or the panu, as a tool for survival.
“‘Survival’ is a more accurate description of what we do,” states a
text crawl that prefaces the first volume. The tape approaches the
bandanna as an expression of flexible weapons in the Spanish-Filipino
tradition, knowledge that Keating and ComTech consider universal in
application.
As I watched the tapes I followed along (that’s me at right)
and applied everything I could, drafting a training partner when
necessary. While I do not believe I mastered all the techniques
demonstrated in the time I practiced the material, I achieved a much greater
appreciation for flexible weapons in general and for the bandanna
specifically. I believe this points to the genuine utility of these
tapes, though I think you’d have to be as accomplished a martial artist as Mr.
Keating to be able to do with comparable efficacy everything he demonstrates.
Tape One covers knife defenses, dealing with secondary
attacks, and “miscellaneous ideas for development.” Tape Two
is devoted to basic engagement skills, “oxygen denial” (choking
techniques), intermediate fighting concepts, and the bandanna’s uses as a
survival and emergency tool.
Production values on both tapes are quite acceptable.
The blue cloth background is very… blue… but the video is bright enough
(except for a little darkness towards the lower portion of the screen) and the
techniques are demonstrated with reasonable clarity. The sound is a
little hollow, but audible throughout. In both volumes, graphic text
appears over the video at the bottom of the screen to emphasize certain points
as Keating makes them, drawing the viewer’s attention to key ideas.
Camera angles change as needed to focus on the action.
VOLUME ONE
In Tape One, Keating welcomes the viewer and introduces the
concept of the bandanna. He explains that any flexible weapon, from a
belt to a rope to a sleeve, can be used with the techniques he demonstrates on
the tapes. He then demonstrates tying a knot in the end of the bandanna
(not a Thuggee knot in the middle) and promises to show the viewer how to
“load” the bandanna to make it a more effective striking tool.
“A lot of people think this is a joke,” Keating
explains, “But it’s a serious weapon.” He is quite
right; I have heard the “Fighting Bandanna” concept derided
before by those speaking from ignorance. Mr. Keating appreciates, as
should we all, the need to adapt common objects to the cause of self-defense.
Keating then demonstrates snapping the bandanna using the
knotted end as a handle, practicing his targeting in both horizontal and
vertical directions. The backhand, overhand, underhand, and inward snaps
are all demonstrated.
The substance of Tape One is defense against the
knife. Keating demonstrates several techniques — while cautioning
students never to train with a real knife — that involve using the bandanna
(and the thumbs of your hands where applicable) to deflect, trap, redirect,
and otherwise counter incoming blades, following up as applicable. Many
of the techniques involve wrapping the knife itself with the bandanna, using
the flats of the blade to avoid having one’s kerchief cut in two. This
is probably the most difficult part of this material to achieve in real life,
at least in my opinion, as one must be extremely precise in dealing with an
incoming knife in this way. Mr. Keating, of course, does it with little
effort, as one would expect from someone of his ability.
The integration of footwork and other tools — kicks, head
butts, etc. — is not neglected. After covering several different knife
defenses with the bandanna, Mr. Keating stops to review what he has just
covered, which nicely sums up the segment for the student.
In the segment on dealing with secondary attacks, Keating
demonstrates using the bandanna to deal with weapons other than knives.
He uses it to attack the haft of a tomahawk, for example, and also discusses
reverse grip variations. Some of his techniques turn into other
maneuvers like wrist locks. There are times when he seems to be relying
on the protection of the leather cuff he wears on his wrist, which is fine if
you regularly wear such a thing (as Keating does in most pictures of him I’ve
seen).
As he covers dealing with punches from the off side as well
as other secondary attacks, Keating reiterates the point of the Fighting
Bandanna tapes — the use of less-than-lethal force to subdue and
enemy. “I’m not saying to be kind to an enemy,” he points
out. “Be cruel. But control them without doing lethal
force. That’s what this video is about.” He also states, more
than once, that the bandanna as flexible weapon should be approached conceptually
— not as a catalog of techniques, but as a body of principles that can be
applied to any flexible tool.
“Remember,” he tells the viewer, “It’s all
mental.”
What looks like FMA, Aikido, Ju Jitsu, Wing Chun, and a host
of other techniques is all on display as Keating continues to demonstrate
various counters and takedowns with the bandanna. In one sequence he
practically hogties his opponent with his kerchief.
In the the segment on miscellaneous tools for development,
Keating fulfills his promise to show the viewer how to “load” the
bandanna with an end weight to make it a very effective striking
tool. He also shows how to use the bandanna to secure a
knife in the palm of one’s hand. He demonstrates how to tie a few useful
knots, such as a fisherman’s knot and bowline knots, then makes a double loop
to convert his bandanna into a pair of makeshift handcuffs. The tape
even includes advice on how to use a light scarf to work one’s arm
muscles. The volume concludes with contact information for ComTech.
VOLUME TWO
In the second tape in the set, Keating focuses on defeating
an unarmed adversary. He speaks again about loading the bandanna for
striking and also examines using it as a sling to hurl projectiles.
Going back to targeting with the bandanna as a striking tool, he emphasizes
hitting the hands and face (because strikes to the body will do little
effective damage by comparison).
The segment on basic engagement skills is devoted to
“baiting” the opponent — drawing him in to reduce the variables one
faces, effectively countering attacks on various lines. Taking the
opponent’s balance, redirecting his attack, parrying, and drilling both sides
of the body in developing these skills are all covered.
The first thing of which most people think, when considering
the bandanna or any flexible tool as a weapon, is that it can be used to
strangle or choke an enemy. That is the topic discussed in the segment
on “oxygen denial,” during which Keating demonstrates using the
bandanna to both counter an attack and transition into a choke and/or control
maneuver. He uses the bandanna to great effect in moving his opponent’s
head around, levering him about and dominating him mechanically.
Moving on to what he considers intermediate fighting
concepts, Keating uses the bandanna for both “speed trapping” and
one-hand trapping. This is really more of an overview than anything else
— one that points to Keating’s exceptional skill. (I’ve mentioned that
several times in the course of this review, but it’s impossible not to comment
on it when watching Mr. Keating work.) “Random thoughts and
ideas” are presented to give the student a variety of techniques and
concepts with which to work, including traps and counters used against kicks.
Finally, Mr. Keating speaks about using the bandanna for
“healing” — what I would consider emergency preparedness and
survival techniques. He touches on everything from using one’s kerchief
as a head cover, particle mask, head band, pressure-point binding tool,
tourniquet, and defense against snow blindness to using the leverage it
affords to stretch another person’s spine. He walks the viewer through
the correct application of the bandanna in each case.
“Concentrate on the healing aspects as well as the
fighting aspects,” he exhorts. This is an important message, for it
points to the mission of ComTech as more than simply fighting
efficiency. I think the term “holistic survival” does it
justice.
More than once, Keating encourages students to experiment
with the tools and principles presented, learning what they can do and
exploring the concepts. “Everything we do can be defeated or
‘overrode,” he says early in Tape One. “…Don’t
compete. Don’t horse around. …Work together.”
Those
are wise words and the approach that should be taken in learning from these
tapes.