It’s one of the most profound things I’ve heard of self-defense over the years: Just because it worked doesn’t mean it works… and just because it didn’t work doesn’t mean it doesn’t work.
The question of whether a technique, a method, a martial art, or even a strategy will work lies at the heart of all discussion about self-defense. There is a cottage industry online — and there has been for years — of declaring that such-and-such a technique won’t work, such-and-such a martial art is useless, so-and-so an exponent of such-and-such system is a bed-wetting pansy who can’t punch his way out of a wet paper bag, and so on.
The reason it’s so easy to proclaim that a technique, a system, or a person doesn’t work or can’t fight is because all discussion of self-defense is largely theory. Unless you’re going out and getting into actual fights, you have very little idea what you’ll actually do when someone is trying to murder you. You have no idea if the things you’re training to do will serve you well or fail you “for real” unless you’ve done them for real. In civilized society, this relegates most self-defense and martial arts training to the realm of theory.
You can mitigate these issues. Realistic levels of contact and resistance, including asymmetrical training that is “alive” in nature, are best. This is training that allows for techniques to be trained at or near full speed and full force, through scenario training, combat drills, padded assailant and torso dummy work, etc. Of less value is sparring, which nonetheless has value. It’s definitely a great way to get comfortable with applying techniques on a resisting opponent and with testing your abilities and your resolve in a relatively “safe” environment. The problem with sparring for self-defense training, though, is one of mindset. It (unavoidably and by definition) turns what should be an asymmetrical conflict into a symmetrical contest.
When sparring, both opponents are trying to win on the same grounds and within the same context. The way to win a self-defense altercation is not to fight the other fellow fairly, after all. It is to avoid the fight entirely if you can and employ a grossly unfair strategy and method (such as using a force multiplier in the form of a weapon) if you must. This is why the notion of “pressure testing” a technique is only true to a point. Unless that opponent is trying to murder you, your technique or method is only “proven” within a controlled sporting context. Yes, you may be very skilled at Brazilian Ju Jitsu… but those “proven” techniques become something else entirely when the man you’ve just pinned starts stabbing you.
Let’s circle back around, then, from proclamations of what does and does not work — of varying degrees of value — to the concept itself. What does that statement — “just because it worked doesn’t mean it works… and just because it didn’t work doesn’t mean it doesn’t work” — actually mean?
Everybody can tell a story about a ridiculous technique that should not have worked, yet did. Many long-time students of martial arts can also recount bitter stories of their training failing them when they were attacked “for real.” I know a young lady who used a technique straight from her Wing Chun class that allowed her to subdue a drunken lout at a concert who tried to get a little too “hands on.” I know another, rather obnoxious British bobby who was fond of telling anyone who would listen that a Karate reverse-punch was all he’d ever needed “on the street.” Anecdotes abound. What they have in common is that you may be able to pull off an improbable technique and you might fail to apply a “high-percentage” technique. The context matters.
More broadly, anyone can lose a fight at any time. Anyone can have a bad day. Anyone can make a mistake. And anyone can get lucky. Some of you are more confident in what you do than others of you. That confidence may be well founded or it may be unrealistic. In the case of the latter, there will one day come a reckoning that you will find unpleasant. It’s up to each of us to determine if we fall into that camp or not.
While we can dress it up with an air of scientific analysis by calling them “high percentage” and “low percentage” techniques, almost everything works sometimes. A wrist lock that won’t work on a mugger (unless you shove a thumb in his eye first) might be just the thing to subdue your drunken Uncle Phil at a party when he’s getting out of hand. A good, solid round kick will almost always work, in that it will impart force reliably to the target; a punch to the face will work whenever your fist can take it and his jaw can’t; a knife in the guts will “work” in that it will do serious, possibly lethal harm to the opponent (but may not stop him from hurting you before he dies). A “pressure point strike” that relies on “chi” and woo-woo wishful thinking will never work.
The mistake some make is in declaring an all-or-nothing judgment on entire swaths of martial training occurring in the world. We can no more say that all traditional martial arts don’t work than we can say that all mixed martial arts training does. Tae Kwon Do has become, in many circles, a watered down joke, but Tae Kwon Do as practiced in Korea can be quite brutal and effective. There are numerous awful Wing Chun schools out there, but also some incredibly adept practitioners of that system who absolutely would kick your ass if you tried to mug them. There are Mixed Martial Arts exponents who have been killed by much less fit, much less skilled individuals who had knives. There are reality-based self-defense instructors who have been shot on their way to gun-disarm seminars.
The list goes on. We can no more arrogantly proclaim that all practitioners of a given style or system “can’t fight” than we can say that all of them can — unless and until we evaluate every single one of them. Even if we have a high degree of confidence (or lack thereof) in a style, system, or category of “fighting,” there are always exceptions. Sparring (to a degree), rolling with someone (to a greater degree), and combat drills with appropriate resistance and contact (to a matching or even better degree) will help you identify those techniques and methods that tend to work. The results will always be subject to context, to individual skill, to individual will, and yes, to luck.
Reduced to its absurd conclusions, what this means is that absolutely nothing works in self-defense. Fortunately, though, we know that it can and does. This is reality, which at times can be harsh. It is all the hope and impetus we all need to keep on training.
Very, very profound thinking. Filled with many accurate assessments of the chaos of physical violence. Keep up the good work Phil!
So my having been in a life and death attack back in 2001 when I was 42 where I was given the “citizen hero of the year” for LA and multiple other awards from the state legislature and The city of LA for going from victim to disarming/apprehending one of LA’s most wanted gives me a bit of insight in to this. In the end the guy I handed over to the cops received 308 years.
First, I never thought of my possibly dyeing during the attack, I sure did two days later…
Second, when the gun was in the back of my neck, I gave my wallet and played his game as all good Martial Arts schools teach “your life isn’t worth a dollar amount”.
My Martial Arts background: judo from age 13 till 19, (5-7 days a week) including competition to National level wins and Junior Olympic wins.
From age 20-27, 1st instructor for Gene LeBell at City College in LA. We actually practiced eye gouges, crushing throats(bar arm chokes), the twist and pulling of man bits. All in “moves” and theory, but nothing real of course.
Gene LeBell always said when in a fight with a guy use what ends it and use what the other guy doesn’t know(I guess Rhonda Rousey forgot that one in her boxing loss to the boxer) 2 of the 3 of these I used when I was in nonlife threatening fights where my “thinking brain” was working. In my life and death fight my thinking brain gave way for what I knew worked, almost like muscle memory.
Third, everything slowed down in the life and death fight. Even slower than in tournament judo(where you are thinking ahead almost Chess like). You know or have seen your opponent use right side Seoi nage in prior matches so your counter is right at the top of your list of what to use and as he is in the air you realize your “muscle memory” does it faster than your thinking brain. Probably the best part of doing tournament judo.
After I handed over the wallet the guy proceeded to pistol whip me. By the 6th time I had went down with my brain paying attention like no other time in my life. It is a violent story that followed. It was like a snake with a mouse after I got my hands on him. My brain was racing so fast from just before I disarmed him (when I was on the ground facing down with his gun in my back) til the cops arrived. I can tell you honestly I was trying to figure out how to kill him for all the adrenaline filled minutes after I disarmed him and choked him out several times. Easy now with 4-5 options with my thinking brain but with your “muscle memory” brain running things it is for sure different.
There are no superior martial arts, only superior martial artists…
These are very interesting observations.So many variables to consider.A running and jumping in air front kick followed with a standard back fist allowed me to finish an opponent quickly in a parking lot when I was 23 yrs.old. The same efforts today would put me in the hospital once I started the running portion. It really depends………
Thanks for the article, nice read.
Not much leeway for disagreeing with the content, but maybe an addition… After retiring from 20+ years from working in and outside nightclubs in a very “busy” environment & after coming out relatively unscarred, I realized the only thing that really works reliably is being scared every time you head off to a shift 😀
Thanks for the continuous quality, keep up the good work.
A quality article that very much addresses an issue I am having today with my own training. I.e. the lack of reality. The lack of raw aggression and the sense of immediate danger. I love tour concept of symmetrical and asymmetrical training. Those terms sum up exactly where sparring becomes less effective for defence training over comp training. Thanks
Good stuff.
Great article. I tend to ignore everyone’s criticism of other martial arts, because it almost always is just about self aggrandizement.
The problem with ALL training is that it is done in a context where neither you nor your sparring partner are actually trying to kill or maim each other. You both know that while you may get a few owies neither of you will be seriously injured, and certainly not killed. That lack of realism colors everything. The way you fight when you’re sparring is inherently different from the way you’d react and fight if someone attacked you with the intent of injuring or killing you. The awareness that your life is in imminent danger changes your mental state, your motivation, your willingness to use any tools and means necessary to survive, and your level of fear. I don’t know how to realistically simulate that state, or even if it’s possible to do so.
Very good text and reflection, this youtube trend and also people trend x martial art vs y martial art…. I allways say, itś not the martial art is the person… And accordding to what you say that we all have bad days, a good fighter might not be in the mood for fight… I allways say, fighting is about two things: “Mood” and timming…. Doesn’t mather if the technic is good or bad if reachs a certains target in the right timming can be a K.O…. But of course a person who trains have more chance than a person who doesn’t, anyway timming and mood will make the day!
Beautifully articulated blog on evaluating survival when life is at threat. Great job!
Excellent article that will become required reading for my students.
Respects,
Steve Kohn
I thought this was a good article, because it addressed that when you step out of the ring and onto the streets – context is everything.
To tell a story along the lines of that point: a year and a half ago, I was a security guard at a drug store in a rough neighborhood. Drunks, drugs, panhandlers, etc – if you name it I probably had to deal with it at some point. Where context mattered most is when I had to deal with armed robbery. Fortunately I only had to deal with one incident like that; but it opened my eyes. I hear shouting, go to investigate, and then there it was: a shotgun straight out of Resident Evil held by a guy wearing a mask and screaming for the money. The cashier had made a run for it, the manager was hunkered down in the pharmacy while the pharmacist called 911. I stared down the barrel of that thing from about a car length away for two minutes, and I can say with ten thousand percent certainty: there was nothing I could do except beg for my life. Explain that I had no way to open the registers or the safe; and just pray to God that he didn’t blast me a structurally superfluous new orifice. He left, of his own accord, and let me live. I have consumed dozens if not handfuls of weapon disarm videos from multiple disciplines from BJJ to Krav Maga; and I know for a fact that doing anything other than what I did would have sent me home in a box.
Context is everything.
I learned this back when I used to do sport fencing. I went up against guys who had been training for decades who could very reliably pick me apart, but I would still get points on them here and there. The instructor would often remind people to stay humble, since no matter who your opponent is, how skilled you are, or how inexperienced your opponent is, you’re gonna get stabbed eventually. Bad luck and ugly chance can be minimized by training, but never wholly eliminated.
I know this is an old article, but it’s very well written I needed to make a comment on here. I’ve been telling guys for years about grappling on the ground is great.. But like every system, it’s not 100% perfect. I’ve also brought up (as you have) people DO carry weapons for self defense and if your on the ground, and that guy has a knife, it’s not going to end well for the person who is trained in grappling. I hope you are doing well, Stay safe, be well.